Wrong seed again! - Page 3

honeythedog · December 26, 2010

Quote:

Seed Suppliers Needed

We need more seed suppliers so that we can offer our customers a wider range of tomato seeds. We are constantly looking for rare and obscure varieties that will introduce and offer UK growers a diverse selection. Please contact us if you are a supplier of seeds and may be able to help with this project.

(From their "down for maintenance" website)

mmarston · August 25, 2011

In 2010 I got seeds for Goldmans Italian American from Terroir Seeds. These tomatos were so good that I got seed from them again this year. The Goldmans are large, ribbed, and pear shaped This new seed produced some other more typical Italian paste tomato. No Goldmans at all. They are sending me new seeds. How about a few bushels of Goldmans?

BigBrownDogHouse · August 25, 2011

Wow! What a tomato in that first shot!

I'm learning this happens quite a bit.
When I discover that something I am growing isn't what it is suppose to be, I just hope it is at least a good tomato. Better luck next time!

mmarston · August 25, 2011

That Goldman was a little bigger than a softball. I spent some time on the photo as I was posting it to pizzamaking.com. The other photo was just for evidence.
I guess I have to save the seeds next time but I barely have time to keep the garden up.

I highly recommend the Goldman's for sauce and they're quite tasty raw as well.

SmartAlex · August 26, 2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by Worth1

Just to set the record straight I have NEVER had the wrong seed sent to me from Tomato Growers Supply.

Good company but I got Pineapples last year that grew some smallish, round red tomatoes. The plant I gave my mother was the real McCoy. I didn't even have a seed in the house that was supposed to do that.

mmarston · August 26, 2011

Most of my unknown paste tomatoes are still green and may not survive Hurricane Irene. I'm well inland but the weather predictions are not good.

ScottinAtlanta · August 26, 2011

I ordered this year from Ohio Heirloom Seeds. Great and friendly service. Anyone know them?

halleone · September 16, 2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by mmarston

In 2010 I got seeds for Goldmans Italian American from Terroir Seeds. These tomatos were so good that I got seed from them again this year. The Goldmans are large, ribbed, and pear shaped This new seed produced some other more typical Italian paste tomato. No Goldmans at all. They are sending me new seeds. How about a few bushels of Goldmans?

Well, phoo! I wanted to order Goldman's for next year, but now I'm a bit edgy about it. If someone has old seeds that came true, how 'bout you PM me, and see if we can come up with something. Please??

Mike Maurer · September 16, 2011

I grew Goldman's Italian American for the first time this year too and I got both styles of tomatoes from the same plant. Mine were from Baker's heirloom seeds. I read that double and single fruits were the norm from ths plant. I had a few doubles that were near 16 oz. and then some singles that were almost 1/2 that. I had two plants and both did the same thing although neither was real prolific. I have saved seed and will happily share if anyone would like to try this particular strain.

**carolyn137** · September 16, 2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by halleone

Well, phoo! I wanted to order Goldman's for next year, but now I'm a bit edgy about it. If someone has old seeds that came true, how 'bout you PM me, and see if we can come up with something. Please??

I think it would be best if you listed your want in the Wanted subforum of the Seed Exchange where more folks would see it b'c not everyone reads this Forum.

Just a gentle suggestion.

Goldman's Italian American was a selection from a hybrid and while I assumed the selection was genetically stable from what I'm reading that may not be true.

patty_b · September 16, 2011

I got both single and doubles from GIA this year. My giant one spoiled before I could get seeds collected as it split when I tried to pick it.

halleone · September 16, 2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by carolyn137

I think it would be best if you listed your want in the Wanted subforum of the Seed Exchange where more folks would see it b'c not everyone reads this Forum.

Just a gentle suggestion.

Goldman's Italian American was a selection from a hybrid and while I assumed the selection was genetically stable from what I'm reading that may not be true.

A gentle suggestion from a gentle woman!
And thank you for the suggestion.

hmacdona · September 17, 2011

ScottinAtlanta,

I have ordered from Ohio Heirloom Seeds as well. Never had any trouble with wrong seed, germination has always been great. They give nice generous quantities with reasonable prices too.

mmcd75 · October 10, 2011

I have also ordered from Ohio Heirloom Seeds, I was very happy with the items I received and the prices. I will be ordering from them again soon.

afrance30 · October 10, 2011

Quote:

I have ordered from Ohio Heirloom Seeds as well. Never had any trouble with wrong seed, germination has always been great. They give nice generous quantities with reasonable prices too.

I have also had good experience with Ohio Heirloom Seeds.

August 25, 2011	#33
BigBrownDogHouse Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jan 2011 Location: Northern Illinois ZONE 5a...wait now 5b Posts: 906	Wow! What a tomato in that first shot! I'm learning this happens quite a bit. When I discover that something I am growing isn't what it is suppose to be, I just hope it is at least a good tomato. Better luck next time! __________________ Brian

August 25, 2011	#34
mmarston Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Sep 2010 Location: Altamont NY Posts: 3	That Goldman was a little bigger than a softball. I spent some time on the photo as I was posting it to pizzamaking.com. The other photo was just for evidence. I guess I have to save the seeds next time but I barely have time to keep the garden up. I highly recommend the Goldman's for sauce and they're quite tasty raw as well.

August 26, 2011	#36
mmarston Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Sep 2010 Location: Altamont NY Posts: 3	Most of my unknown paste tomatoes are still green and may not survive Hurricane Irene. I'm well inland but the weather predictions are not good.

August 26, 2011	#37
ScottinAtlanta Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Atlanta, Georgia Posts: 2,593	I ordered this year from Ohio Heirloom Seeds. Great and friendly service. Anyone know them?

September 16, 2011	#39
Mike Maurer Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Rio Rancho, New Mexico Posts: 105	I grew Goldman's Italian American for the first time this year too and I got both styles of tomatoes from the same plant. Mine were from Baker's heirloom seeds. I read that double and single fruits were the norm from ths plant. I had a few doubles that were near 16 oz. and then some singles that were almost 1/2 that. I had two plants and both did the same thing although neither was real prolific. I have saved seed and will happily share if anyone would like to try this particular strain.

September 17, 2011	#43
hmacdona Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Calgary, AB Canada (Zone 3A) Posts: 443	ScottinAtlanta, I have ordered from Ohio Heirloom Seeds as well. Never had any trouble with wrong seed, germination has always been great. They give nice generous quantities with reasonable prices too.

October 10, 2011	#44
mmcd75 Tomatovillian™ Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Arizona Posts: 41	I have also ordered from Ohio Heirloom Seeds, I was very happy with the items I received and the prices. I will be ordering from them again soon.