My tomato season in Wisconsin is lackluster as well. So many plants and so few tomatoes!! It was too wet and cool here, but I am finally seeing some turning colors. My tomato leaves look horrible as well; I can't remember having such horrible results in years.
I have had luck with the smaller sized tomatoes ripening, an early variety i started from Double Helix farms called Quedlinburger Fruhe Liebe. If it wasn't for that tomato I would be sadly lacking in tomatoes