View Single Post
Old May 24, 2013   #25
RebelRidin
Tomatovillian™
 
RebelRidin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Maryland's Eastern Shore
Posts: 993
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Durgan View Post
Well boys and girls I assume you will all be saving the largest potato available as seed. This will raise hell with the automatic planting machines. The potato seed used in these machines has the appearance of small grey stones. In fact when I first viewed them in the most beautiful growing area in Canada, I thought they were stones.

I charge that in general it would be impossible to contribute any significant change in potato size and quantity directly attributable to the seed potato size. There are so many growing variables that regressive analysis is most difficult to apply. The researcher has got a paper out and certainly has given some food for bar room discussions, with no practical significance. And apparently he/she has a non reflective following, who will take every opportunity to propagate the"conclusion" and it will become an Internet concept. Similarly to UPSIDEDOWN TOMATO PLANTERS. I for one wont be planting two pound potato seeds, and see no future for TPS as a common planting source. To each his own.
As I previously noted...

Positive observations and experiences carry weight. They add to our knowledge and enrich our lives. Negative observations and experiences do not.

Negative observations, at their best, serve to confirm and reinforce positive things we already believe. Negative experiences though, like weeds in the garden, are a detraction and if left unchecked become injurious. To prevent that they must at times be pulled.

I have to wonder if that may the inevitable end here. It has happened before.
__________________

George
_____________________________

"The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants. It is it’s natural manure."
Thomas Jefferson, 1787
RebelRidin is offline   Reply With Quote